SpicyIP is arguably the leading blog for experts on India’s copyright machine. Still, hyperlinks to it disappeared from Google’s Seek index following a fraudulent copyright infringement claim filed through Saregama, India’s oldest document label. The label claimed that a professional document from 2010 on the history of Bollywood music, referred to as “Apni To Jaise Taise,” infringed on the copyright to the tune. It did now not. Luckily for SpicyIP, they have no shortage of copyright specialists who can argue their case with Google’s takedown system and that they were reinstated.
However, that is a bad omen for the future of free expression in India, which is considering rules much like Europe’s catastrophic Article 13, which might automate censorship of whatever is claimed as copyright without any requirement that these claims be straightforward or made inappropriate religion. Regardless of being aware-and-takedown, it’s miles obvious that setting a duty to police copyright infringement on intermediaries creates perverse economic incentives on non-public events like Google or YouTube to over-comply and takedown felony content material. This is not entirely a result of the intermediaries’ practices; however, the coverage and felony selections created are supposed to strike stability in getting entry to information and copyright safety inside the virtual age.
Record label censors copyright legal professionals’ website by falsely claiming it infringes copyright
